Layover Flights: Brutal Truths, Secret Perks, and Why 2025’s Flyers Can’t Afford to Ignore the Layover

Layover Flights: Brutal Truths, Secret Perks, and Why 2025’s Flyers Can’t Afford to Ignore the Layover

26 min read 5087 words May 29, 2025

You know that moment in the terminal, an hour into your layover, when you start questioning every decision that got you here? Maybe you’re wrapped in the sterile glare of fluorescent lights, half-heartedly sipping stale coffee, watching travelers power-nap on hard benches. Here’s the thing: layover flights are the most misunderstood hack—and trap—in modern air travel. In 2025, they’re not just a pit stop between A and B. They’re battlegrounds for savings, epic fails, and unexpected adventure. We’re about to drag every myth, risk, and opportunity into daylight. From airlines’ hidden incentives to the dark arts of “hidden city” ticketing, and from loyalty hacks to visa nightmares, this is your no-BS guide to layover flights. Put your assumptions in the overhead bin—and let’s dissect the brutal truths and secret perks that airlines would rather you overlook.

The anatomy of a layover flight: more than just a stop

What is a layover flight really?

Most people toss around “layover” like it’s just a fancy word for “connection.” In reality, a layover flight is any trip segment where you change planes en route to your destination, usually with a scheduled stopover of less than 24 hours for international, or under 4 hours for domestic flights. But here’s where it gets fuzzy: not all layovers are created equal, and airlines love to keep it that way.

Departure board showing layover flights and connection times Alt text: Departure board showing layover flights and connection times at a busy airport, with highlighted connections and layover durations

Let’s break down some essential terminology:

Layover
: A scheduled stop between flight segments, typically under 24 hours internationally, or under 4 hours domestically. Example: New York to Bangkok via Frankfurt—Frankfurt is your layover.

Stopover
: A longer break (24+ hours international, 4+ domestic). Airlines like Emirates often turn these into mini-vacations with free hotel or tour perks.

Connecting Flight
: Simply any flight itinerary involving a plane change. All layovers are connections, but not all connections are true layovers.

Self-Transfer
: When you book separate tickets and handle your own re-check-in and baggage. Riskier, but sometimes cheaper if you know what you’re doing.

Hidden City Ticketing
: Buying a ticket with a layover in your real destination, then skipping the final leg. Airlines hate this for a reason—more on the ethics and risks later.

Understanding these terms isn’t just semantic. It determines your rights, your risk, and, sometimes, your wallet’s fate.

Types of layovers: technical, stopover, self-transfer, and the notorious 'hidden city'

Layovers come in more flavors than that mystery meat at airport buffets. Here’s the breakdown:

TypeRisk LevelFlexibilityCost PotentialExample ScenarioProsCons
Technical LayoverLowNoneNeutralForced refueling or crew change, stay onboard or in transit areaNo extra hassleNo exploration, forced wait
StopoverModerateHighHigh SavingsMulti-day break; some airlines offer perks (hotel, tours)Free perks, explore new citiesVisa issues, extra planning
Self-TransferHighVery HighVery HighYou book separate tickets, baggage not automatically transferredChoose airlines, save bigMissed connections = stranded, luggage risk
Hidden City TicketingVery HighMediumExtreme SavingsBook NYC-CHI-LA, exit at CHIHuge savingsAirline penalties, no checked bags, loyalty points revoked

Table 1: Comparative breakdown of layover types by risk, flexibility, and cost. Source: Original analysis based on Dollar Flight Club, 2025 and AviationA2Z, 2025.

Contrasting airport scenes showing various layover types Alt text: Contrasting airport scenes showing various layover types, from crowded transfer areas to luxury lounges

Type matters. A self-transfer via two budget carriers can save you hundreds but puts everything—from your luggage to your sanity—on the line. A stopover with Emirates, though, could mean a night in a five-star hotel, gratis.

Why layovers exist: the airline economics nobody talks about

Here’s the dirty secret: airlines don’t schedule layovers because they’re worried about your wallet or wanderlust. The entire global air network is about maximizing aircraft utilization and filling seats—fast. Airlines use hub-and-spoke models, routing passengers through central airports to maximize routes and minimize empty seats. This is how you end up flying Houston to Chicago via Dallas—for less than the direct fare.

“Layovers aren’t about efficiency for travelers—they’re about profit optimization for airlines. Every hub is a profit engine, and every layover fills another seat.” — Marcus Cheung, airline analyst, AFAR, 2025

In 2025, flight prices have dropped up to 15% compared to late 2023, according to AFAR, due in large part to aggressive competition and smarter route planning. Airlines are doubling down on layovers to chase profits, which means you can often score fares up to 40% cheaper if you’re willing to play the layover game. But sometimes, that “cheaper” route comes with hidden costs—missed connections, visa complications, and more.

Mythbusting: layover flights aren’t what you think

Layover flights are always cheaper—right?

It’s one of travel’s most persistent legends: layover flights equal guaranteed savings. The truth? Sometimes, yes—sometimes, hell no. According to aggregated data from Dollar Flight Club (2025), layover flights can be up to 40% less expensive than direct routes, especially on competitive international legs like New York–Istanbul or Houston–Chicago via Dallas. But in saturated markets, or on certain routes, direct flights undercut layover options, especially during flash sales or off-peak times.

Route ExampleAverage Direct FareAverage Layover Fare% DifferenceCheapest Option (2025)
Houston–Chicago (via Dallas)$310$185-40%Layover (via Dallas)
LA–London (various layovers)$790$610-23%Layover
NYC–Orlando (peak season)$205$234+14%Direct
Paris–Bangkok (Emirates stop)$1,120$930-17%Layover (Emirates/Doha)
Tokyo–Seoul (budget carriers)$430$455+6%Direct

Table 2: Statistical summary of direct vs. layover flight prices, 2025. Source: Original analysis based on Dollar Flight Club, 2025 and AviationA2Z, 2025.

It boils down to timing, competition, and how willing you are to play the system. Sometimes, layovers backfire—especially when last-minute demand surges for what seem like “cheap” connections, or airlines have exclusive rights on direct routes.

Layovers mean guaranteed misery (and other outdated myths)

Let’s kill some myths—and not with mercy.

  • You’re stuck in the terminal with nothing to do: Not in 2025. Many airports (Singapore, Doha, Istanbul) offer gyms, spas, gardens, and even movie theaters.
  • Layovers always mean longer travel times: Sure, but when used right, the extra hours can mean deep savings or a bonus adventure.
  • You’ll lose your luggage: Statistically, most mishandled bags are tracked and delivered within 24 hours, and the risk drops when sticking to one airline alliance.
  • No perks for layover passengers: Wrong. Emirates, Turkish, Royal Jordanian, and others routinely offer free hotel nights, meals, and even guided city tours for long layovers.
  • All layovers are equal: See earlier—self-transfers and stopovers are a different species.
  • Layovers ruin sleep and health: Strategic layovers can actually ease jet lag by breaking up long-haul fatigue.
  • You’ll always miss your connection: In reality, global data shows only about 4-6% of international layovers involve missed connections, down from 10% a decade ago.

Research from AviationA2Z (2025) confirms: the “layover hellscape” is a dying breed, replaced by increasingly passenger-friendly airports and targeted perks.

“I landed in Doha with a 10-hour layover, expecting the worst. Instead, I got a city tour, a five-star lounge, and a nap pod. It changed how I travel—now I look for opportunities, not just inconvenience.” — Leah G., frequent flyer, AFAR, 2025

The layover lottery: why some connections are a gamble

Still, not every layover grants you a golden ticket. According to AviationA2Z (2025 data), the risk of missed connections, delays, and “layover disasters” varies dramatically by airport, airline, and season.

AirportMissed Connection %Main Causes“Disaster Index” (1-10)
London Heathrow (LHR)7.4%Security, gate changes8
Frankfurt (FRA)6.8%Immigration, tight windows7
Chicago O’Hare (ORD)6.3%Weather, layout confusion7
Paris Charles de Gaulle5.9%Gate busing, staff strikes8
New York JFK5.3%Delays, poor signage6

Table 3: “Layover disaster index”—top airports for missed connections, 2025. Source: Original analysis based on AviationA2Z, 2025 and Dollar Flight Club, 2025.

Look beyond the ticket price. Check minimum connection times, airport layouts, and—critically—if you’ll need to re-clear security or immigration. When in doubt, add at least a 90-minute buffer for international layovers.

The dark side: hidden risks and how to avoid them

Missed connections: anatomy of a travel disaster

Picture this: You touch down late in Frankfurt after a stormy Atlantic crossing. The gate agent shrugs—your Istanbul connection’s already boarding… at the other end of the airport. You sprint, heart pounding, but the doors close in your face. Now you’re stranded, faced with rebooking, accommodation, and a hard lesson in layover roulette.

  1. Don’t panic: Stay calm, check your ticket for airline obligations.
  2. Head to the airline desk: Get rebooked—if both legs are on the same ticket, you’re usually covered.
  3. Get documentation: Ask for a written statement of the delay.
  4. Know your rights: EU261 or similar regulations may entitle you to compensation.
  5. Ask for amenities: If delay is long, push for hotel/meal vouchers.
  6. Contact your insurer: Get guidance and start a claim if needed.
  7. Rearrange downstream plans: Notify hotels, transfers, or meeting contacts ASAP.
  8. Document everything: Receipts, correspondence, and boarding passes—all crucial for claims.

Layover mishaps can cost hundreds in rebooked tickets, meals, and lost bookings. Risk is mitigated by booking on one ticket, leaving enough buffer, and knowing your rights.

Visa traps, lost luggage, and insurance pitfalls

International layovers are legal minefields. Some countries require visas even for transit. Others demand you clear customs and immigration regardless. And if you’ve checked baggage, beware: in self-transfer scenarios, you must collect and re-check it—potentially passing through security and passport control again.

Transit Visa
: A short-term visa for passengers changing planes in a country. Example: U.S. airports require all transiting travelers to clear immigration, even if not staying.

Schengen Zone
: Europe’s border-free area. Layovers inside Schengen mean you clear immigration only once, but connections involving non-Schengen airports can be complicated.

Through-checked Luggage
: Bags transferred automatically to your final destination. Not available with separate tickets or some budget carriers—plan accordingly.

Traveler facing visa control during a layover flight Alt text: Traveler facing visa control during a layover flight, looking uncertain at an international customs checkpoint

It’s not just about paperwork. Insurance may not cover self-transfer missed connections or certain visa issues. Always triple-check transit rules and policy fine print.

Red flags: warning signs your layover could go wrong

  • Tight connection times (under 60 minutes international)
  • Different airports in the same city (e.g., LGA to JFK)
  • Separate tickets on non-allied airlines
  • Overnight layovers with no clear accommodations
  • Visa or customs requirements you haven’t researched
  • Airports notorious for delays, strikes, or confusing layouts
  • Peak travel periods (holidays, weather season)
  • Lack of through-checked luggage, especially on budget carriers

Ignore these at your peril. A missed detail can turn “cheap flight” into wallet-busting saga.

“The biggest mistake? Assuming your bag will follow you, or that an hour’s enough to cross an airport like CDG. We see it every day—travelers blindsided by things they could’ve checked ahead of time.” — Janet, airport worker, AviationA2Z, 2025

Layover goldmines: turning lost hours into epic experiences

How to hack a layover: mini-vacations and micro-adventures

Here’s where savvy travelers flip the script: a long layover isn’t wasted time—it’s a mini-vacation hiding in your itinerary. With the right prep, a 10-hour stop in Istanbul or Singapore can become a culinary tour, cultural deep-dive, or spa retreat.

  1. Research visa and entry rules for your layover city.
  2. Pre-book airport storage for luggage you don’t want to schlep.
  3. Identify must-see attractions within 30-60 minutes of the airport.
  4. Download local transit apps—many airports have direct trains to the city center.
  5. Schedule a backup plan if flight is delayed.
  6. Leave a buffer for security checks on your return.
  7. Grab local cash or cards for transit/tickets.
  8. Choose experiences wisely—think proximity and reliability.
  9. Book ahead for popular tours (some airports offer free excursions).
  10. Document everything—photos, receipts, and times to avoid missing your next flight.

Some cities roll out the red carpet: Singapore Changi’s free city tours, Doha’s luxury lounges, or Dubai’s quick-hit desert safaris turn layovers into unforgettable chapters.

The world’s best airports for layovers (and worst—avoid these)

Not all airports are created equal. The best are engineered for the traveler stuck in limbo, offering everything from nap pods to rooftop pools. The worst are soul-crushing labyrinths of delays, rude staff, and dismal food.

AirportLounge QualityTransit OptionsFree AmenitiesSleep Options“Layover Friendliness”
Singapore Changi (SIN)ExcellentDirect MRTGardens, toursNap pods, hotels10
Doha Hamad (DOH)Excellent24/7 taxisPools, art toursLounges, hotels9.5
Amsterdam Schiphol (AMS)GoodRail, tramsMuseums, showersLounges8.5
Paris CDGPoorBus, trainFewLimited5
London Heathrow (LHR)AverageExpress trainBasicExpensive hotels6

Table 4: Feature matrix comparing top and bottom layover airports by amenities and sleep quality. Source: Original analysis based on AviationA2Z, 2025.

Modern airport lounge designed for long layovers Alt text: Modern airport lounge designed for long layovers, featuring comfortable seating and amenities for layover flights

Choose wisely. A good airport can turn a dreaded layover into a self-care sanctuary; a bad one can destroy your entire trip.

Unconventional uses for layover flights

  • Business networking: Many travelers arrange meetings during long layovers, turning idle time into career opportunity.
  • Remote work: With fast Wi-Fi and quiet lounges, airports double as pop-up offices.
  • Wellness retreats: Yoga rooms, massage services, and even meditation pods are showing up in top airports.
  • Side gigs: Digital nomads use layovers to freelance or consult virtually.
  • Micro-volunteering: Some travelers coordinate short stints with local charities during city layovers.
  • Skill learning: Layovers become time for language lessons, cooking classes, or local art tours.

Case in point: One traveler turned a Tokyo layover into a sushi masterclass, while a Berlin stop became the setting for a job interview that launched a new career. This isn’t just about killing time—it’s about wringing every drop of value from your journey.

The trend is clear: as airports adapt, expect more creative ways to turn layovers into something you might actually look forward to.

Layover strategy: expert tactics for 2025 and beyond

How to choose the perfect layover (it’s not what you think)

Forget the old formula of “shortest wait wins.” Strategic layovers in 2025 demand a nuanced approach:

  1. Prioritize airline alliances for through-checked bags and smoother transfers.
  2. Check visa/transit rules before booking.
  3. Aim for layovers of 90+ minutes (domestic) or 2+ hours (international).
  4. Research the airport’s amenities—free tours, showers, rest zones.
  5. Balance cost vs. risk—cheaper fares aren’t always smarter.
  6. Book on one ticket, not separate itineraries, unless you know the risks.
  7. Time your layover for daylight hours if exploring the city.
  8. Avoid airports with high “disaster index.”
  9. Consult reviews and real-time updates—futureflights.ai and similar platforms surface key intel fast.

futureflights.ai, with its AI-driven search, cuts through noise, matching you to layovers that actually work for your goals—whether that’s savings, adventure, or stress-free travel.

Advanced layover hacks: hidden city ticketing, self-transfer, and more

Hidden city ticketing is the rebel move: buy a cheaper multi-leg ticket, but exit at your “hidden” destination mid-route. The risks? Airlines can void your return ticket, strip loyalty points, or even ban you. But for the bold—and careful—it can mean hundreds in savings.

Self-transfer means piecing together separate tickets for maximum flexibility and price cuts. But if your first leg’s delayed and you miss the next? You’re on your own.

Legally, airlines are cracking down on these hacks in 2025. Ethically, you decide—just know the risks.

“Hidden city ticketing is an art and a gamble. You can save big, but don’t expect the airline to be happy if you’re caught. Always travel with carry-on only, and be ready for consequences.” — Aiden W., travel hacker, Mighty Travels, 2025

Mistakes to avoid: what even seasoned travelers get wrong

Travelers—rookies and road warriors alike—fall for these traps:

  • Booking separate tickets without researching minimum transfer times.
  • Ignoring visa requirements for layover countries.
  • Cutting layover times too close.
  • Assuming all airlines will transfer bags automatically.
  • Overlooking airport amenities (or lack thereof).
  • Forgetting to check for “layover perks” from the carrier.
  • Not reading the fine print on insurance or ticket refunds.

Stay sharp. The best layover isn’t necessarily the fastest—it’s the one that aligns with your real travel goals.

Case studies: layover legends and cautionary tales

The layover that went viral: from disaster to legend

In early 2024, a group of travelers en route from Sydney to London found themselves stranded in Doha after a sandstorm grounded flights. Rather than sulk, they organized a spontaneous group tour, documented every moment on social media, and turned a would-be disaster into a viral sensation. Not only did they explore the city’s art scene and souks, but their story was shared by airlines as a model for positive layover culture.

Next-level improvisation saved the day, but luck played a role—visa-free entry, a world-class airport, and open-minded companions.

Travelers making the most of an unexpected layover adventure Alt text: Group of travelers celebrating in an unexpected city, making the most of a layover adventure

Three real layover disasters (and what the data says)

  • Frankfurt missed connection: Bad weather delayed inbound. Traveler missed self-transfer connection, had to purchase new ticket ($480 loss).
  • NYC layover visa denial: Traveler from Brazil denied entry at JFK due to expired visa, forced to sleep in airport and rebook via alternative route.
  • Heathrow baggage nightmare: Bag not through-checked on separate tickets, lost for three days; essential medication delayed, health scare ensued.
IncidentKey FactorPreventable?Solution
Missed connectionTight timingYesBook longer layover, one ticket
Visa denialPaperwork errorYesCheck transit visa rules in advance
Lost baggageSeparate ticketsYesCarry-on or same airline/alliance

Table 5: Breakdown of layover disasters and prevention strategies. Source: Original analysis based on AFAR, 2025 and AviationA2Z, 2025.

Lesson: The layover lottery can be cruel—but with research and prep, most disasters are avoidable.

Winning the layover lottery: stories of unexpected windfalls

Some travelers walk away from layovers with more than just souvenirs. Take Derek, a New York designer en route to Seoul, who struck up a conversation in a Tokyo lounge and landed a new client. Or the student who used a 12-hour layover in Amsterdam for a portfolio review that led to a job. These aren’t accidents—they’re the product of curiosity and preparation.

“That one layover changed my career. I never even planned it, but being open to what the airport—and its people—offered made all the difference.” — Derek H., creative professional, AFAR, 2025

The lesson? The real “layover lottery” rewards those who show up ready for anything—and know how to play the odds.

Layovers and the future: AI, ethics, and the evolution of flight

How AI-driven search is rewriting the layover playbook

AI isn’t just changing how you book flights—it’s changing which flights you book. Platforms like futureflights.ai sift through millions of options, flag hidden perks, predict disruptions, and surface personalized layovers tailored to your risk profile and interests.

The upside: less guesswork, smarter itineraries, and more control. The downside: overreliance on algorithms can mask personal preferences or unique needs. In 2025, the best travelers blend AI with good old-fashioned street smarts.

AI-powered flight search interface optimizing layover options Alt text: AI-powered flight search interface optimizing layover options for travelers in 2025

Ethical and environmental debates: layovers under the microscope

Not all layovers are created equal environmentally. Research shows that extra takeoffs and landings increase carbon emissions—sometimes by up to 20% compared to direct flights.

Route ExampleDirect Emissions (kg CO₂)Layover Emissions (kg CO₂)% Difference
LA–London (direct)1,0501,260+20%
NYC–Tokyo (direct)1,3201,485+12%
Paris–Bangkok (direct)9501,120+18%

Table 6: Comparative carbon emissions of direct vs. layover flights. Source: Original analysis based on AFAR, 2025 and AviationA2Z, 2025.

This raises the ethical question: should you always chase the cheapest route? The answer is personal, but as sustainable aviation tech develops, expect this debate to intensify.

What’s next? The future of layovers in a changing world

Industry forecasters expect the following trends by 2030:

  • More airports offering free city tours and cultural programs for layover passengers.
  • AI routines personalizing layovers based on mood, past behavior, and weather.
  • Airlines expanding stopover perks to win loyalty.
  • Governments tightening or easing transit visa requirements based on traveler demographics.
  • Growing eco-pressure for carbon offsetting and sustainable layover routing.
  • Rise of “micro-layover” tourism: 6-10 hour curated excursions.

Travelers who stay flexible, informed, and tech-savvy will thrive in this new ecosystem. The layover isn’t just here to stay—it’s evolving fast.

The ultimate layover survival kit: tools, tips, and checklists

Must-have gear for thriving, not just surviving

Comfort and productivity are non-negotiable if you’re spending hours between flights. Here’s what the pros pack:

  • Noise-cancelling headphones: Block out chaos, catch up on rest.
  • Portable charger and adapters: Outlets are scarce, especially in older terminals.
  • Reusable water bottle: Stay hydrated and skip overpriced airport drinks.
  • Collapsible tote: For snacks, layers, or last-minute shopping.
  • Travel pillow and eye mask: Turn any bench into a nap pod.
  • Snacks: Airport food can be a gamble.
  • Lightweight change of clothes: Freshen up after a red-eye.
  • Printed copies of tickets/visas: Tech can fail—paper doesn’t.
  • Compression socks: Reduce fatigue on long haul connections.

Essential items for surviving long airport layovers Alt text: Essential items for surviving long airport layovers, neatly arranged on a bench with travel gear and amenities

Quick-reference: top apps, sites, and resources

Stay ahead of layover surprises with these digital essentials:

  1. futureflights.ai: AI-powered flight and layover recommendations.
  2. FlightAware: Real-time flight tracking and delay forecasts.
  3. LoungeBuddy: Find and book lounges worldwide.
  4. TripIt: Consolidates itineraries and notifies of schedule changes.
  5. Google Maps: For airport layouts and transit to city centers.
  6. Priority Pass: Lounge access and amenity alerts.
  7. Rome2Rio: Maps out transport options from airports to city attractions.

These tools cut through confusion and help you pivot fast if plans change.

Layover self-assessment: are you ready?

Before you click “book,” ask yourself:

  1. Do I need a visa for my layover country?
  2. Will my checked bag transfer automatically?
  3. Is my layover airport known for delays?
  4. Do I have enough buffer time between flights?
  5. What amenities are available at this airport?
  6. Can I leave the airport and return easily?
  7. Am I insured for missed connections?
  8. Are both flights on the same ticket—or am I self-transferring?
  9. Do I know local transit options?
  10. Is this layover worth the risk and opportunity cost?

Get these answers wrong, and the “savings” can vanish quickly.

Beyond the layover: what every traveler should know before booking

Direct, stopover, or layover: which is right for you?

Each option has tradeoffs:

FactorDirectStopoverLayover
CostHighest, but stableMedium, possible perksLowest, but variable
RiskLowModerate (visa/logistics)Higher (missed connections)
ExperienceFastest, most boringTurns trip into two vacationsPotential adventure or disaster

Table 7: Comparison of direct, stopover, and layover flights. Source: Original analysis based on Dollar Flight Club, 2025 and AFAR, 2025.

Choose direct for speed and certainty, stopover for cultural bonus rounds, and layover for cost savings or if you crave a bit of chaos.

When a layover makes sense—and when to avoid it

Layovers are the smart move when:

  • Saving $100+ matters more than an extra half-day in transit.
  • You want to explore a new city for a few hours or days.
  • Your risk tolerance is high and you have backup plans.
  • The airline offers generous stopover perks.

But skip the layover when:

  • You’re on a tight schedule (weddings, work, tight connections).
  • Traveling with small children or mobility issues.
  • Layover airports have a high disaster index.
  • You can’t legally enter the layover country.
  • You’re hauling lots of luggage or gear.
  • It’s peak travel season and delays are rampant.
  • The savings just aren’t worth the risk or hassle.

If the risks outweigh the rewards, book direct and sleep better—literally.

Conclusion: why it’s time to rethink the layover (and how to own your journey)

Here’s the bottom line: layover flights are a double-edged sword. Used wisely, they unlock savings, adventures, and even life-changing encounters. Mismanaged, they can unravel your travel plans—fast and painfully. In 2025, the best travelers aren’t the ones with the fanciest upgrades, but those who approach every layover with curiosity, strategy, and a healthy respect for the unexpected.

So next time you’re staring down a multi-hour stop in a strange city, remember: this isn’t just dead time. It’s a blank page, waiting for you to write your next story. With the right tools—like futureflights.ai’s intelligent search and a streetwise sense of risk—you can turn the layover into your advantage.

Traveler embracing the adventure of layover flights in 2025 Alt text: Traveler confidently striding through an airport, city lights beyond, embracing the adventure of layover flights in 2025

Embrace the layover revolution. The best trips aren’t always the most direct—they’re the ones where you own every leg of the journey.

Intelligent flight search

Ready to Discover Your Next Adventure?

Experience personalized flight recommendations powered by AI